Brooklyn Pizzeria

Faith Allen 2 months ago

Stumbled upon this place while I waited for my daughter’s driving lesson. The staff were friendly upon entry. The young girl at the register was professional and helpful with the menu. I ordered the all the way slice of pizza and lemon pepper wings. It was so good. One slice was more than enough.

DENISE FOX 3 months ago

I’ve loved this place ever since I’ve discovered it while visiting our daughter at the university in Fayetteville. I stopped in recently and noticed the fresh updates with new paint and remodeled restrooms. I had a chance to talk with one of the owners, who said they’re keeping the same recipes and ingredients everyone loves while adding a few new menu items. The owners were so friendly, and the pizza is still just as delicious as ever. It’s great seeing the place get a fresh look while keeping the same great food. We’ll definitely be back!

Jeff Kugel 3 months ago

Im somewhat of a pizza snob. This is by far...and i really do mean by far the best pizza I've found in North Carolina. We moved here a little over 5 years ago and have been basically making pizza from scratch for quite awhile because the pizza in this area is absolutely garbage. We've been about 6-7 times now. The pizza is perfectly cooked. The sauce is flavorful and not overly sweet. There isnt too much or too little cheese and the crust...FINALLY a freaking pizza cust that actually tastes like pizza crust. Its been consistently perfect. Nice crisp, but still soft, crunchy as well as chewy and you can actually taste the variations in flavor with the proper spotting on the under. Its incredibly well done. Ive had a couple sandwiches now have nothing but good things to say. The prices for a couple slices and a drink are also extremely reasonable. Im gonna go smash that brooklynator challenge soon... Go...if you like decent pizza go. You won't be disappointed. 10/10 and again, by far the best pizza within 50 miles. Should also add that every single time we've been...they have been very very nice, quick, courteous and the place was clean.

Michi Rivera 8 months ago

Holy moly!!!!! I been searching for an authentic New York style pizza since I moved to North Carolina! And I come across the beauty. Keep in mind I've tried 2 other places that have said "New York style pizzeria" so walking in here I was already skeptical and I walked in there asking if this was legit New York style pizza and the cashier who is such a sweet soul! Said they all from New York and I was like ok ok well she sat waiting didn't wait to long and here comes the pizza WHEN I TELL U CRUNCH ✅ GREASE DRIP ✅ SIZE ✅ FLAVOR ✅ this is a must go to spot for the New York style pizza!!! The atmosphere is amazing. Very clean place and the ppl working there are even just the most wholesome ppl!!! I love it!! For sure coming back!!!

Denese Edwards 2 years ago

Quaint pizzeria with old school Brooklyn charm. Staff was engaging and nice. I ordered the Stromboli and found it very flavorful with a crisp yet soft crust texture. The sausage was mild and tasty, and the pepperoni gives it a hint of spice. Loaded with melted mozzarella and mushrooms. I took home my leftovers, and if you like cold pizza, it was on par and did not fall flat with flavor. I heated up my last third of the Stromboli in the air fryer, and the crust was just like it came out of the oven the first time. Flaky, crispy and wonderful. Will definitely go back.